Home | Discussion | Feedback | Archives | Contact Us
 
The first ever named complaint in this case came on May 7 ,2006 when Nandlal (father of Payal), accused Moninder of having hidden his daughter but police did not act on this complaint for seven months and in htese seven months 8-10 more children went missing.In fact Nandlal had to take the help of the court just to get his F.I.R registered. He was virtually thrown away from the SSP\'s house when he went there a third time begging for help. These are facts which finally came to light. But what did not come out was that this SSP was R.K.S.Rathore and not Piyush Mordia. Piyush Mordia had been transferred from Noida on April 26, 2006 whereas Payal disappeared on May 7, 2006. Is it fair to hold an offficer (who was transferred to another district)responsible for the misdeeds of his successor?
   
Was there an unspoken understanding between RKS Rathore, Dinesh Yadav and B.P.Singh because of which Rathore never recommended action against any one of them.? Did B.P.Singh not write the missing reports because of the instructions of his seniors? Was it due to the instructions from his SSP that Dinesh Yadav did not register Payal\'s case for a long time and filed an affidavit in favour of Moninder singh Pandher & Surinder Koli and let them off inspite of a named report against them?
   
The subordinate officers during whose tenure lapses took place and who were finally held responsible by the court as well - namely Dinesh Yadav (Deputy SP), B. P. Singh Yadav (Station officer) and Simaranjeet Kaur (sub inspector) - all of them got posted to Noida only after Piyush Mordia\'s transfer- none of them has ever worked with Piyush Mordia in his entire career. They were never supervised by him. How could he be held responsible for their lapses or actions? Was he made a scapegoat?
   

 

Piyush Mordia had been transferred from Noida on April 26, 2006 whereas Payal disappeared on May 7, 2006.
Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
Prashant Verma

The first ever named complaint in this case came on May 7 ,2006 when Nandlal (father of Payal), accused Moninder of having hidden his daughter but police did not act on this complaint for seven months and in htese seven months 8-10 more children went missing.In fact Nandlal had to take the help of the court just to get his F.I.R registered. He was virtually thrown away from the SSP's house when he went there a third time begging for help. These are facts which finally came to light. But what did not come out was that this SSP was R.K.S.Rathore and not Piyush Mordia. Piyush Mordia had been transferred from Noida on April 26, 2006 whereas Payal disappeared on May 7, 2006. Is it fair to hold an offficer (who was transferred to another district)responsible for the misdeeds of his successor?

 
 
   
Showing total 21 REPLIES
 
Nice site!
 
Replied By : Nikolet
Replied On : Thu, 20th Mar, 2008
 
 
It is quite shocking to see that these kind of glaring facts which are speaking for themselves were not made known to the authorities by the concerned people and the injustices have perpetuated that long. I wish some good journalist take up the cause and show to the people their right places
 
Replied By : Mukesh Joshi
Replied On : Wed, 23rd Jan, 2008
 
 
This is outrageous and absolutely ridiculous that Mordia was held responsible. The judicial machinery needs to look at the whole enquiry process to redress the wrong done to an officer who is one of the few humane faces in UP police machinery
 
Replied By : ashish
Replied On : Thu, 10th Jan, 2008
 
 
There are no words that can sum up the injustices that are going around in the world. Only Divine intervention can bring about the much-needed retribution. Alas! When will this happen?
 
Replied By : Asma Raheem
Replied On : Fri, 4th Jan, 2008
 
 
This must be so frustrating for the officer who was unjustly targetted. No wonder there are very few good officers left! God save the country.
 
Replied By : Suhhash Shah
Replied On : Thu, 3rd Jan, 2008
 
 
We should have some constitutional changes to make responsible the concerned; our constitution was written a long back. Now the situation in the country is different at present. We should have special arrangements for these types of culprits. It is not fair to hold an officer (who was transferred to another district) responsible for the misdeeds of his successor. Who so ever is/are responsible are required to be punished? As per my opinion the accused are required to be hanged till death. They are responsible for the end of growing lives. They are not the human being. We should treat them like the animals.
 
Replied By : sanjeev Kumar
Replied On : Mon, 31st Dec, 2007
 
 
Thank you for your friendly invitation to share the
 
Replied By : Farag BenAzouz
Replied On : Sun, 30th Dec, 2007
 
 
No, I don't think it is fair by any standards but who is there to listen to truth when the people in the decision making capacity are blinded by their biases, vested interests and corruption
 
Replied By : Sanjay Tripathi
Replied On : Wed, 26th Dec, 2007
 
 
What can I say! Can there be a bigger example of injustice inflicted by the so called law makers and protectors of the Constitution? If the governments continue to make these kinds of blatantly unjust actions it would be at the cost of demise of civil services as an institution in the times to come
 
Replied By : Ash
Replied On : Tue, 25th Dec, 2007
 
 
This happens only in India.where lies and liars are saved and the truthful people have to proove their innocence
 
Replied By : Parineeta
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
It is interesting to see that in matters which can be verified lies are spoken so openly. What is even more shocking was that Rathore was allowed to get away with it.
 
Replied By : Rahul Bhargava
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
We were amazed to go thru these columns. These facts never reached the people.It appears that media was never given the real picture but is it not the role of the media to verify the facts .Who is going to compensate the aggreived officers and their families for the torment they have suffered
 
Replied By : Ruby and Alka
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
If the media is misguided by a senior police officer where will a common man go for redressal of his grievances. it is no fair to hold mordia guilty
 
Replied By : Haender Patel
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
HATS OF TO Mr. Rathore that inspite of the fact that he was guilty, he was successful in manipulating and manouevering the whole incident by directing the blame on another officer who had been transferred before this heinous crime took place
 
Replied By : Alok Sharma
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
THAT IS WHY UTTAR PRADESH IS ULTA PRADESH
 
Replied By : AAKANKSHA GUPTA
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
I have heard that when this issue came to light, Mr Rathore boasted that nothing would happen to him because he was very close to the ruling party. He said that he was part of the family as he was from the same place as Mulayam Singh, and that the outsiders could be made the 'bali ka bakra'. Obviously he was successful, and poor Piyush Mordia was punished for no fault of his.
 
Replied By : Yogesh Agarwal
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
This is utterly disgusting! They actually suspended an officer who wasn't even there when this happened? This can only happen in India, and more so in UP. In any other country, a fair inquiry would have revealed the correct facts. This is indeed shameful.
 
Replied By : Shelendra Kothari
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
This is not surprising at all. Rathore must be close to the powers that be in UP. The guilty always go scot free in UP and the innocent always are left holding the bag.
 
Replied By : Shilpa Shah
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
When a senior police officer like Rathore acts in this manner, he should be punished and piyush mordia can not be held responsible for non registering of Payal's case.
 
Replied By : Sammy
Replied On : Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
 
 
When an officer has been transferred, he can not be held guilty for the lapses of his successor . But what is surprising is that what seems to be basic common sense is actually not so common in the minds of the govt. God help such a state.
 
Replied By : sushila godha
Replied On : Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
 
 
I'm sure it must be having a very demoralising effect on Officers to be punished for no fault of theirs. Laws must be made to see that action when taken against officers should be done after thorough deliberation and not just in the heat of the moment .Otherwise our system will go from bad to worse.
 
Replied By : rishabh
Replied On : Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
 
Untitled Document
Copyright © 2007 NITHARIFACTS.COM | DISCLAIMER