Home | Discussion | Feedback | Archives | Contact Us
 
The first ever named complaint in this case came on May 7 ,2006 when Nandlal (father of Payal), accused Moninder of having hidden his daughter but police did not act on this complaint for seven months and in htese seven months 8-10 more children went missing.In fact Nandlal had to take the help of the court just to get his F.I.R registered. He was virtually thrown away from the SSP\'s house when he went there a third time begging for help. These are facts which finally came to light. But what did not come out was that this SSP was R.K.S.Rathore and not Piyush Mordia. Piyush Mordia had been transferred from Noida on April 26, 2006 whereas Payal disappeared on May 7, 2006. Is it fair to hold an offficer (who was transferred to another district)responsible for the misdeeds of his successor?
   
Was there an unspoken understanding between RKS Rathore, Dinesh Yadav and B.P.Singh because of which Rathore never recommended action against any one of them.? Did B.P.Singh not write the missing reports because of the instructions of his seniors? Was it due to the instructions from his SSP that Dinesh Yadav did not register Payal\'s case for a long time and filed an affidavit in favour of Moninder singh Pandher & Surinder Koli and let them off inspite of a named report against them?
   
The subordinate officers during whose tenure lapses took place and who were finally held responsible by the court as well - namely Dinesh Yadav (Deputy SP), B. P. Singh Yadav (Station officer) and Simaranjeet Kaur (sub inspector) - all of them got posted to Noida only after Piyush Mordia\'s transfer- none of them has ever worked with Piyush Mordia in his entire career. They were never supervised by him. How could he be held responsible for their lapses or actions? Was he made a scapegoat?
   

 

Did B.P.Singh not write the missing reports because of the instructions of his seniors?
Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
Prashant Verma

Was there an unspoken understanding between RKS Rathore, Dinesh Yadav and B.P.Singh because of which Rathore never recommended action against any one of them.? Did B.P.Singh not write the missing reports because of the instructions of his seniors? Was it due to the instructions from his SSP that Dinesh Yadav did not register Payal's case for a long time and filed an affidavit in favour of Moninder singh Pandher & Surinder Koli and let them off inspite of a named report against them?

 
 
   
Showing total 13 REPLIES
 
I guess the questions raised above are more of a rhetorical questions and the answers are self evident. What is not evident is the redressal of the wrongs done and perpetuated by the beaurocratic and political machinery.
 
Replied By : Ashish
Replied On : Wed, 23rd Jan, 2008
 
 
The axis of evil is right here - in India.How can such corrupt people continue to occupy good positions in society? Just like America has a war on terror, India should have a war on corruption, and people like B.P. Singh should be sent to Tihar jail.
 
Replied By : Kanak Mishra
Replied On : Thu, 3rd Jan, 2008
 
 
I can smell a dead rat can't you? What is surprising that so obvious questions were not raised by the
 
Replied By : Harish Kumar
Replied On : Wed, 26th Dec, 2007
 
 
I am not surprised. The police thana raj has been victimising people since the British Raj . What is surprising was that these people managed to victimise their own colleagues and seniors
 
Replied By : Dr Rajesh Mittal
Replied On : Tue, 25th Dec, 2007
 
 
I agree with Ash's suggestion of having a judicial enquiry of the enquiry commitee.It seems that judiciary is the only institution left on whose fairness we can rely
 
Replied By : Praveen Goenka
Replied On : Tue, 25th Dec, 2007
 
 
The questions raised above are very legitimate and should have been followed up by the so called enquiry of the state government which was a mockery of the system in India.That enquiry was neither free, nor fair nor helped to bring out the facts. It infact crusified the innocent one in the whole incident. Infact there should be a judicial enquiry on the original enquiry committee of the Nithari incident and subsequent actions of the state government.
 
Replied By : Ash
Replied On : Tue, 25th Dec, 2007
 
 
I am sure it would not take a rocket scientist to figure that they were all together in this. I shudder to think what would have happened if the investigation would not have gone in the hands of the C.B.I.With these very officers investigating the case we would never have known the truth
 
Replied By : Mayank Verma
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
It is strange that senior police officers like Rathore still believe in high handedness in dealing with such heinous crimes and are protected by senior officers. This is criminal negligence
 
Replied By : Shakuntala Singh
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
There must be A CONSPIRACY . Chor Chor mosare bhai. That is the reason they all kept quiet.It is impossible for a junior officer to do things without knowledge of his s.s.p
 
Replied By : Sheel Godha
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
Yes , such a big cover up cannot be done without the knowledge of top officers
 
Replied By : Dilbagh Singh
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
All the people were involved, and that is why they were protecting each other. Rathore should be dismissed, for taking bribe from such a shameless person, and for covering up such a heinous crime.
 
Replied By : Baldev Singh
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
Yes , it obviously seems like that. It is because of such connivances that even the biggest murderers gets away scotfree
 
Replied By : Kunal kapoor
Replied On : Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
 
 
I could never imagine ki hamaree hindi movies truth ke kitna kareeb hoti hain! this seems to be a plot fit for bollywood.Rathore should be punished.
 
Replied By : shefali goyal
Replied On : Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
 
Untitled Document
Copyright © 2007 NITHARIFACTS.COM | DISCLAIMER