Home
 
The first ever named complaint in this case came on May 7 ,2006 when Nandlal (father of Payal), accused Moninder of having hidden his daughter but police did not act on this complaint for seven months and in htese seven months 8-10 more children went missing.In fact Nandlal had to take the help of the court just to get his F.I.R registered. He was virtually thrown away from the SSP\'s house when he went there a third time begging for help. These are facts which finally came to light. But what did not come out was that this SSP was R.K.S.Rathore and not Piyush Mordia. Piyush Mordia had been transferred from Noida on April 26, 2006 whereas Payal disappeared on May 7, 2006. Is it fair to hold an offficer (who was transferred to another district)responsible for the misdeeds of his successor?
   
Was there an unspoken understanding between RKS Rathore, Dinesh Yadav and B.P.Singh because of which Rathore never recommended action against any one of them.? Did B.P.Singh not write the missing reports because of the instructions of his seniors? Was it due to the instructions from his SSP that Dinesh Yadav did not register Payal\'s case for a long time and filed an affidavit in favour of Moninder singh Pandher & Surinder Koli and let them off inspite of a named report against them?
   
The subordinate officers during whose tenure lapses took place and who were finally held responsible by the court as well - namely Dinesh Yadav (Deputy SP), B. P. Singh Yadav (Station officer) and Simaranjeet Kaur (sub inspector) - all of them got posted to Noida only after Piyush Mordia\'s transfer- none of them has ever worked with Piyush Mordia in his entire career. They were never supervised by him. How could he be held responsible for their lapses or actions? Was he made a scapegoat?
   

 


None of them has ever worked with Piyush Mordia in his entire career.
Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
Prashant Verma

The subordinate officers during whose tenure lapses took place and who were finally held responsible by the court as well - namely Dinesh Yadav (Deputy SP), B. P. Singh Yadav (Station officer) and Simaranjeet Kaur (sub inspector) - all of them got posted to Noida only after Piyush Mordia's transfer- none of them has ever worked with Piyush Mordia in his entire career. They were never supervised by him. How could he be held responsible for their lapses or actions? Was he made a scapegoat?

 
 
   
Showing total 12 REPLIES
 
Ilike the idea mentioned above about a of movie with this kind of plot being made. But i think instad of Lalita Pawar we can have Bipasha Basu .She looks good n hot in negative roles and i would suggest Anupam kHer as Rathore. Even Danny is a good choice for him, For dinesh Yadav gulshan grover could be fine and for Piyush mordia, I would prefer sHAHRUKH with his 6 pack abs.n lets give Hritik n ash also some role in it. Fit movie masala
 
Replied By : maher
Replied On : Tue, 4th Mar, 2008
 
 
I can only say that the judicial system/True journalism should intervene to bring the perpetrators of this COVER-UP crime (which is equally if not more henious than actual Nithari killings) to justice. A wrong decision like this leads to demoralisation of the Police force and the right individuals concerned.
 
Replied By : Ashish Jain
Replied On : Wed, 23rd Jan, 2008
 
 
I cannot believe that such things can happen. A movie should be made - Dinesh Yadav can be played by Prem Chopra, B.P. Singh by Gulshan Grover, Simranjeet Kaur by Lalita Pawar. Piyush Mordia could be portrayed by Abhishek Bachchan, and Mr Rathore by Nana Patekar. Did someone say super-hit?
 
Replied By : Arun Sharma
Replied On : Thu, 3rd Jan, 2008
 
 
The above mentioned fact clearly reveals a serious error of judgement and whether it is an error of ommission or commission it doesn't matter what is important is this needs to be rectified as far as and as soon as possible.
 
Replied By : Praveen jain
Replied On : Wed, 26th Dec, 2007
 
 
If these officers had never worked under Mordia, he should not have been made a scapegoat
 
Replied By : Nazli Khan
Replied On : Tue, 25th Dec, 2007
 
 
Of course, Mordia was made a scapegoat. One does not need to be Ramanujan or Albert Einstein to add two and two! The whole situation after Nithari incident was a sham in terms of government's actions. The incident in itself was sad and unfortunate beyond imagination further followed by a series of events which smells corruption, conspiracy, blame shifting, communal/caste politics.
 
Replied By : Ash
Replied On : Tue, 25th Dec, 2007
 
 
Common sense is sometimes not very common. But it is surprising that at such a senior level it is missing .If these people were not posted during his time it is basic logic that he could not be held responsible for their mistakes. By that logic yes , he was made a scapegoat
 
Replied By : Varsha Sanyal
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
I was amazed to go through this information . It is really shocking that a guilty person is left completely free while another officer is being punished for somebod's else's misdeeds.
 
Replied By : Abhay Saxena
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
There is no other such incident in police history where a guilty officer has successfully managed to put the blame for his misdeeds on another officers head and was successful in misleading the media also
 
Replied By : P K CHITTORA
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
In light of this, it is obvious that Piyush Mordia had no role in this cover up, and all the cover up happened during Mr Rathore's time. It was he who did not take action against the complaints and he took bribe from Surender Singh. He should be immediately dismissed, and sent to jail
 
Replied By : Abhijeet Goswami
Replied On : Mon, 24th Dec, 2007
 
 
In view of the above it is time to read between the media coverage & the official comments that are deliberately misleading. As aware & concerned citizens we demand immediate action on the people actually guilty.
 
Replied By : Saurabh K
Replied On : Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
 
 
Oh yes, most definitely - if this chap Mordia has not remained the supervisory authority of these people , he can not be blamed for their lapses-
 
Replied By : Priya
Replied On : Sun, 23rd Dec, 2007
 
Untitled Document
Copyright © 2007 NITHARIFACTS.COM | DISCLAIMER